Black Circle Boys (1997)

*Get a physical copy of "Black Circle Boys" on Amazon here*
*Watch "Black Circle Boys" on Amazon Prime Video here*
*Get "Black Circle Boys" wall decor on Amazon here*
*Get a copy of Born: Giving Birth to a New You by Dee Wallace on Amazon here*

A young hunky cast transcends a couple of cliches and marketing mistakes to make a watchable suspenser, based on a true story.

Kyle (Scott Bairstow) is an All-American swimming high school student who loses his best friend on a night their swim club was celebrating. Months later, Kyle's distant dad (Bruce Burkhartsmeier) and mother (Dee Wallace) move to the Pacific Northwest to start fresh. Kyle is troubled, sulking into a new school. He meets modern-day flower child Chloe (Tara Subkoff), and also runs into creepy Shane (Eric Mabius), giggling sidekick Munn (Heath Lourwood), and nerdy peon Rory (Chad Lindberg). Shane has pie-in-the-sky dreams of getting a band together, and grudgingly hires Kyle on as a drummer. Shane's life revolves around drug use and causing trouble. He bites the head off a dissection frog in biology class, and holds wild parties in the woods. Kyle falls in with this group immediately, especially after meeting Shane's mentor Greggo (Donnie Wahlberg). The film hits a slow patch as the Black Circle Boys wreak havoc around the town. Shane has the Boys believing he is receiving power from Satan himself, and the hallucinogens feed the lie.

The troubled youth angle has been done to death, and writer/director Matthew Carnahan steps into some of this cliche once in a while. His direction is fascinating, however. This is not a typical slasher film. Carnahan does some very imaginative tracking and hand-held shots, lending it a documentary feel. The picture seems washed out, all the colors match the gloomy, cloudy weather. You can see the actors' breath in many of the cold nighttime scenes. Bairstow looks genuinely pained as the troubled Kyle. Stone is great as his mother, her timid stance in his room is a highlight. Mabius as Shane is equally good in a creepy role. He is just a punk, but a scary punk. Wahlberg is unrecognizable as Greggo, but his part is terribly underwritten. Lisa Loeb has just a couple of lines, without her trademark glasses, and her name was tacked on to cash in on her new found popularity back then. The video company was marketing this as a horror film, and I found it in the horror section at a video store, but that angle is all wrong. The film has crime, suspense, but no supernatural angle other than Shane's lies. "Black Circle Boys" compares favorably to other hunks-in-trouble films like "The Skulls." It is not perfect, the same story has been done a hundred times before (and is based on the actual Ricky Kasso case), but the acting and directing set it above the others.

Stats:
(1997) 101 min. (* * * *) out of five stars
-Written and Directed by Matthew Carnahan
-Cast: Scott Bairstow, Eric Mabius, Donnie Wahlberg, Tara Subkoff, Dee Wallace, Heath Lourwood, Chad Lindberg, Bruce Burkhartsmeier, Lisa Loeb, John Doe, Richard Sanders, Victor Morris
(R)